Final Friday, Elon Musk tweeted a grand unifying idea for America’s path to prosperity. “We have to shift folks from low- to negative-productivity jobs in authorities to high-productivity jobs in manufacturing,” he wrote on X, combining DOGE’s Rapture-style method to downsizing the federal workforce and the supposed reshoring objectives of Trump’s tariffs.
Musk is so keen on this idea, in reality, he has tweeted some variation of it at least eight times since November’s election. All that repetition, nonetheless, has not but rendered the logic behind the idea any extra sound. Musk’s perception that the DOGE firings will create a producing labor power conveniently disregards so many contradictions, no quantity of tweeting may make it any much less absurd. He may as properly whisper the plan right into a seashell.
For starters, classifying all authorities positions as “low- to negative-productivity jobs” in distinction with manufacturing facility employees is a gross generalization. Whether or not it’s impressed by Musk’s boundless contempt for Big Government or only a product of his startup-world effectivity mindset, it’s wildly off base.
If it had been true, the FDA’s well being regulators, who overview medical units and tobacco merchandise, wouldn’t be struggling within the absence of their not too long ago laid-off coworkers, which they are. The remaining IRS brokers wouldn’t be predicting tax compliance will fall this yr as a result of folks making an attempt to slide extra dangerous filings previous a slashed workforce, which they might. And even when Musk had been certainly proper in regards to the authorities using way more loafers than the common enterprise, if DOGE had any actual perception into which employees had been the worst offenders, they wouldn’t repeatedly scramble to rent again fired employees, which they have.
Wanting by means of the lens of Musk’s “low- to negative-productivity” evaluation clarifies why he could have demanded federal workers ship emails itemizing five things they accomplish every week. On this mild, the weekly dispatch turns into an effort to “show” an unlimited productiveness deficit—as if a easily functioning authorities wasn’t proof of the alternative. Taking an enormous leap, although, and assuming Musk has accurately recognized as terminally unproductive virtually everybody in Human Well being Companies, the Social Safety Administration, and different essential departments, why are these particular folks prime candidates for the manufacturing sector?
A number of the many newly unemployed authorities accountants, analysts, and researchers will discover different work simply. Others could battle to land their subsequent jobs. The possibilities are lower than slim, although, {that a} majority of them could have nowhere to go however a hypothetical iPhone manufacturing facility in Milwaukee. It looks as if a misguided revenge fantasy in opposition to members of the regulating businesses Musk has lengthy complained about throttling innovation, from the Securities and Exchange Commission (FEC) to the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). Now, he can—not less than in idea—condemn a few of these businesses’ white-collar employees to lives of handbook labor.
Comparatively few Individuals, although, really wish to work in a manufacturing facility. In line with the Financial Times, current polling exhibits that 80% of Individuals assume the nation could be higher off with extra manufacturing jobs, however solely 25% of Individuals assume that they, personally, could be higher off in such jobs. (Excellent news for everybody who makes up that 25%: The U.S. presently has more open manufacturing jobs than it can fill.)
Only for argument’s sake, although, assuming a big variety of laid-off authorities employees both did need manufacturing jobs or had no viable alternate options, there is no such thing as a assure that the Nice Reshoring will ever come to go. As a lot as insiders like Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick seem convinced Trump’s tariffs will bring manufacturing jobs back, others are skeptical of whether or not that’s even the aim. Senator Chris Murphy, as an example, recently told Fast Company that he thinks Trump is utilizing tariffs “to power industries and firms to come back bend the knee to him and lower offers with him that profit him politically.”
Contemplating it would take years for corporations to ascertain the mandatory infrastructure for home manufacturing, and in an setting the place financial coverage usually seems dictated on a whim, corporations could search alternate workarounds for the tariffs. Confronted with the prospect of transferring manufacturing to America, many corporations will merely diversify manufacturing out of China. Apple, as an example, has been moving more and more iPhone production from China to India and Vietnam over the previous yr, and Walmart has been sourcing more from India as properly. Smaller corporations grappling with the present 145% tariffs on China will probably observe go well with.
Taking part in satan’s advocate, although, let’s assume a large portion of U.S. corporations do decide to reshoring and that 1000’s of former authorities employees present up at these HR places of work, hat in hand. Lots of these “high-productivity jobs in manufacturing” that Musk is keen on mentioning are already earmarked for AI. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent confirmed as a lot final week during an appearance on Tucker Carlson’s show.
Requested by the host whether or not the U.S. has the mandatory labor power for a hypothetical transition again into manufacturing, Bessent stated the next: “I believe we do. I believe with AI, with automation, with so many of those factories . . . they’re going to be good factories. I believe we’ve bought all of the labor power we want.”
Nothing makes Musk’s line about shifting authorities employees to high-productivity jobs appear extra like a sneering troll than Bessent claiming U.S. manufacturing facility jobs are the province of robots. Maybe it’s time Musk shifted to a better likelihood pipe dream.
Add comment